• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Diary of a Semi-Health Nut

ramblings + recipes of a semi-healthy nut

Hi! I’m Amanda.

I’m a writer, chocolate chip cookie baker, blog designer, power walker, Instagram fiend, peanut butter toast lover and copious coffee drinker living in Nebraska with my husband and three cats. (also a fan of a good run-on sentence)

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About
    • The Blog + Amanda
    • Life
    • Best Of DSHN
    • As Seen On
  • Foodie
    • By Type >>
      • Breakfasts
      • Desserts
      • Drinks
      • Entrees
      • Snacks
      • 20 Minute Meals
    • Allergy Friendly >>
      • Dairy Free
      • Gluten Free
      • Vegetarian
    • Restaurant Reviews
    • What I Ate Posts
  • Fitness + Health
    • Fitness Posts
    • Workouts
    • Running Posts
    • Did You Know…
  • Faves
    • Confessions
    • Cookies
    • SHN Favorites
    • Caturday
    • Happy Things
  • amandaRdewitt.com
  • Navigation Menu: Social Icons

    This is an archived site, so not as glorious as the original 🙂

Best Way to Eat Thin Mint Cookies

October 14, 2014 by Amanda R DeWitt

Oh hey how are you?

Me? Just procrastinating my 8 mile long run here in Nebraska (edit to add: I started this post in Nebraska, but sadly I’m not still there. I did manage to get a 7 mile run-walk in though!). You know, since I haven’t exactly been staying on schedule training for my 10 mile race that’s a mere two weeks away with how awfully sick I’ve been feeling…gah. I’m not gonna lie. I’m so nervous for not only the race, but the next couple of training runs!

What better to procrastinate with than a delightful Thin Mint Cookie Pie recipe? This Thin Mint recipe is so decadent with a cookie dough center and chocolate minty cookie crumbles on top layered over a tasty graham cracker crust. Serious self control is involved with this pie so I suggest you share it with friends or family.

thin mint cookie pie via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

Of course you could eat this all yourself…but hopefully not in one sitting. Stick it in the freezer if you are too tempted (<-handy trick).

This recipe is the perfect way to use up the massive amounts of Thin Mint cookies you are hoarding. I mean, if you’re like me or Dave, you get so excited when it’s time to buy Girl Scout cookies that you end up with wayyyy too many Thin Mint Cookies. And I’m not saying there is such a thing as too many Girl Scout cookies…just sometimes you don’t have enough cupboard space to contain your Thin Mint cookie hoarding tendencies. #firstworldproblems right?

thin mint cookie pie using girl scout cookies

This cookie pie was inspired by a Thin Mint Cookie Bar recipe guest post, created for me back in March when I was studying for my big NASM certified personal training test. Gosh has it really been that long since my NASM test??

I actually went back to that post today and made a new, longer graphic in the post specifically for Pinterest. You know you are allowed to do that right? Go back to old posts and spruce them up? I’ve been a Pinterest fiend lately and I’ve definitely learned that the longer images are noticed more so than the wider ones. (I actually owe you all a post soon all about Pinterest since I told myself I would write up some tips once I doubled my followers..from 900 to 1800 and that’s happening soon! Feel free to help! Winking smile)

thin mint cookie pie bite via @semihealthnut

Now these photos were actually taken in March. Some of them are decent, but most of them were awful. Looking back on foodie photos really makes me appreciate how far I’ve come!

I bet you’re wondering why I’m sharing this recipe months later, huh? Well, believe it or not, I don’t share all the recipe I make and photograph. For whatever reason this recipe got shoved to the back burner and I’m busting it out again. I actually might make this for a girls get together this weekend…I hope the ladies like thin mint cookies!

Thin Mint Cookie Pie

thin mint girl scout cookie pie via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

This Thin Mint Cookie Pie is super easy to make..especially if you use a pre-made graham cracker pie crust. Graham cracker crusts aren’t even that hard and only involve 3 ingredients if you want to make one yourself. This graham cracker crust recipe looks closest to the one I remember making with Mama Sue (<- my mom, the baking queen).

So once you have your graham cracker crust, simply whip up the cookie filling and your thin mint cookies crust. This is no doubt a decadent dessert. The cookie filling is nice and soft inside the crunchy thin mint cookies and graham cracker crusts. Like a yummy dessert sandwich. Don’t think about the amount of butter you are consuming. Just enjoy. Smile

[Tweet “I want this Thin Mint Cookie Pie! #thinmint #dessert #sweettooth”]

Pretty please note that the nutrition information is always an estimate (calculated by my recipe plugin) and in this case is for 12 slices. You can certainly tailor the size based on your diet or your current cookie craving. 🙂 

 

use this one amandaTell me….

What’s your favorite Girl Scout cookie? Mine is definitely thin mint!!

When you make desserts, do you share with others? I try..or I stick some in the freezer so I don’t eat it right away!

 

PS I’m all about Pinterest this year, so I would LOVE IT if you could pin one (or two!) of these images!

Pin with me!

Follow SemiHealthNut

Stay in the loop with bloglovin’!

Follow on Bloglovin  

Receive new post, tips + tricks, inspiration + exclusive content right to your inbox!

Linking up to:

What’s Cookin’ Wednesday with Buns in My Oven

Strange But Good with Laura at Sprint to the Table

Show and Share Wednesday with Kelly at Mostly Homemade Mom

Saturday Night Fever

(All of the lovely link-ups I participate in here.)

 

Disclaimer: There are some related amazon affiliate links in this post. There is no additional charge or inconvenience to you, but I do get a small kick-back when you purchase anything using one of my Amazon affiliate links. I truly appreciate the support! 

Related

Filed Under: dessert, food, nut free, recipe, Vegetarian or Vegetarian Friendly Tagged With: chocolate, dessert, food, pie, recipe

About Amanda R DeWitt

I’m a writer, chocolate chip cookie baker, blog designer, power walker, Instagram fiend, peanut butter toast lover and copious coffee drinker living in Nebraska with my husband and three cats. (also a fan of a good run-on sentence)

Previous Post: « The Happy Things Series
Next Post: New Blog Design 2014 »

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Kaylin @ Enticing Healthy Eating

    October 14, 2014 at 9:37 pm

    Oh, yum! Think Mint cookies are the best Girl Scout cookies in my opinion. And this is the perfect dessert for National Dessert Day! Way to celebrate. 😉

    • Amanda @ Diary of a Semi-Health Nut

      October 15, 2014 at 1:26 pm

      I had no idea it was National Dessert Day!! Lucky posting haha

  2. Purelytwins

    October 15, 2014 at 5:09 pm

    oh my!! this is perfect!!! thin mints are the best

    • Amanda @ Diary of a Semi-Health Nut

      October 15, 2014 at 6:13 pm

      Thanks!! I am quite fond of them! 🙂

  3. Laura @ Sprint 2 the Table

    October 19, 2014 at 6:44 pm

    OMG – I think you just won procrastination.

    • Amanda @ Diary of a Semi-Health Nut

      October 25, 2014 at 9:05 pm

      haha yess best way to procrastinate!

  4. Deborah @ Confessions of a Mother Runner

    October 20, 2014 at 6:33 am

    ooh looks dangerously good!

    • Amanda @ Diary of a Semi-Health Nut

      October 25, 2014 at 9:07 pm

      It’s so good! You have to try it!

Primary Sidebar

Dig into the Archives

Browse the Categories

Dessert is the Best

S’mores Cookie Dough Pie in a Skillet

S'mores cookie dough pie in skillet

Grilled S’mores Banana Boats

grilled s'mores banana boats before and after

Banana Funfetti protein Cookies

banana funfetti protein cookies via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

{WIAW #42} Mexican Tacos and Dessert Fail

Chewy Almond Funfetti Cookies + 7 Happy Things

chewy almond funfetti cookies via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com perfect for customizing for any holiday including the 4th of july! #yum #recipe #cookies #dessert

{WIAW #66} Moving Day + Archive Eats

[IMM Link-Up #9] Chocolate Covered Strawberries

chocolate covered strawberries with sprinkles with sprinkles

GF Pumpkin Spice Browned Butter Protein Bites

gf pumpkin spice browned butter protein bites via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

Raspberry Homemade Fruit Roll Ups with Frozen Fruit

easy DIY homemade fruit roll ups. great as a snack, a semi-healthy treat, or for fueling for a run. via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

Frozen Banana Pops Covered in Chocolate Taste Like Dilly Bars

See More >>

Popular Today

How To Make Cake Pops (and keep cake pops on the stick)

Tags

banana (16) birthday (15) blogging + writing (56) Blogging 101 (17) chicken (15) chocolate (19) Christmas (18) coffee (12) confessions (13) cookies (48) dessert (32) Did You Know (22) family (42) fitness (82) food (47) Friday Finds (36) giveaway (16) guest post (47) holiday (14) life (17) link-love (14) link-up (31) MIMM (38) Monday Moves (14) nutrition (21) peanutbutter (22) positivity (15) pumpkin (21) ramble (16) recipe (63) restaurant (22) review (21) running (24) salad (13) school (32) semi-healthy (16) smoothie (16) thankful (23) Thursday Thoughts (17) tips (15) twin cities (27) Uncategorized (17) vegetarian (14) weekend (20) zoeyfluffybutt (14)

Random Random Posts..Good Luck!

9 Fun Ways to Keep Moving This Summer

20 Confessions 12-16-13

How I Make Money Blogging with Ads

Get Fit with Music

{WIAW #52} Moving Fuel + Giveaway Winner

You Know What They Say…

{Recipe Round-Up} What to Take to Thanksgiving

Turkey Loaf…it’s what’s for dinner

Best of 2013: Recipes

{WIAW #25} A Typical May Day at Home

Footer

Random Recipe Machine…Refresh for More!

Merry Baking {Christmas} Eve 2011! (Part 1)

{WIAW #11} What a Semi-Health Nut Eats the day after Christmas

S'mores 3 ways via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

Decadent S’Mores Recipes

{WIAW} Eating with Kiddos + Serving Others

{WIAW #38} Family Time

~*Summertime*~ Sweet Tooth -3 SIMPLE Summery Desserts!!

Happy Pancake Day! Oatcakes Recipe

flaxseed hungry jack waffles with syrup and coffee

Flaxseed Hungry Jack Waffles [ Recipe ]

Copyright © 2025 Diary of a Semi-Health Nut · By Amanda R. DeWitt