• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Diary of a Semi-Health Nut

ramblings + recipes of a semi-healthy nut

Hi! I’m Amanda.

I’m a writer, chocolate chip cookie baker, blog designer, power walker, Instagram fiend, peanut butter toast lover and copious coffee drinker living in Nebraska with my husband and three cats. (also a fan of a good run-on sentence)

  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About
    • The Blog + Amanda
    • Life
    • Best Of DSHN
    • As Seen On
  • Foodie
    • By Type >>
      • Breakfasts
      • Desserts
      • Drinks
      • Entrees
      • Snacks
      • 20 Minute Meals
    • Allergy Friendly >>
      • Dairy Free
      • Gluten Free
      • Vegetarian
    • Restaurant Reviews
    • What I Ate Posts
  • Fitness + Health
    • Fitness Posts
    • Workouts
    • Running Posts
    • Did You Know…
  • Faves
    • Confessions
    • Cookies
    • SHN Favorites
    • Caturday
    • Happy Things
  • amandaRdewitt.com
  • Navigation Menu: Social Icons

    This is an archived site, so not as glorious as the original 🙂

Cake Pops {How to keep them on the stick}

December 13, 2011 by Amanda R DeWitt

Hello Friends!

Hope you all had a great weekend!  Mine was spent relaxing, making cake pops and hangin with family.  Who could ask for anything more??

I am giving thumbs up because I finally got them to stay on the stick!!!

Saturday my friend Malalalalory came over to teach me how to make cake pops.  I realize that cake pops are not new…by any means, but I have never attempted them.  For some reason I had in my mind that cake+frosting+almond bark = too sweet.  This is not true!

Malalalory: my teacher in cake pops making

After many failed attempts at keeping the cake pops on the stick (mine kept falling off!!), I think I discovered the way to keep them on.

The one that died

How to make Cake Pops…and Keep them on the Stick!!

Ingredients:

  • Baked and cooled cakes (we had three and they made 50? 60? a lot)
  • Frosting (we used less than 2 store bought containers)
  • Powdered sugar (helps to hold it together)
  • Almond bark or candy melts
  • Sticks (found at a craft store)
  • Decor for the cake pops (ex. sprinkles)
  • Something to keep the cake pops upright in (we used coffee cups but I’m sure there are other ways) 

P.S.  The BF made 3 cakes for me while I was at work because I spaced the fact that I needed to make them until late at night the night before.  He is kinda sweet sometimes. 🙂

    How To:

    1. Begin to crumble one of the cakes into a bowl.
    2. Add frosting and powdered sugar.  This was all very estimated as Mallory wasn’t sure of the exact measurements.  If you have ever made cookies…try to get them to about the consistency of cookie dough.
    3. You might be able to mix with a spoon…but when I handed mallory a spoon to mix, she looked at me and said, “You’re gonna have to get in there.”  As in with my hands.  So mix up with your hands for best results. 😉
    4. Roll into balls and set on a cookie sheet.  You are not baking them so there is no need to space them out…although I started to stagger them instinctively due to my many years of cookie making.
    5. Put the sticks into the rolled cake balls.
    6. Stick in the freezer for an hour.  In my opinion…this is the key to keeping them from falling off the stick.  If they are frozen, they stay on, however your decorating needs to be quicker the colder they are.
    7. Melt the candy melts or almond bark at 30 second intervals, stirring.  Make sure to read the package as well but the 30 second intervals seem to be best.
    8. Dip frozen cake pops in melted bark or melts and quickly coat and sprinkle.

    Beware…it can get quite messy…or maybe that was just us…

    We eventually figured it was smart to have something to catch the extra sprinkles. 🙂

    Sunday we got together for Mama Sue’s bday.
    Remember when I said that I’m terrible at gift-giving?  Possibly due to the fact that I don’t pay enough attention to what people like…and possibly, thanks to a reader’s comment pointing this out, that gift-giving is probably not one of my top love languages.

    I did manage to get my mom a pretty necklace with the letter “S” on it.  I almost grabbed the one next to it that had “M” on it, but then I realized, her name is Sue, not Mom.  😉

    I also got her a fun mom calendar.  She loves those kinds of things.  (This is one thing I noticed.)  I was going to give it to her for Christmas, but I couldn’t figure out what else to get her for her bday besides the little necklace.

    I also got her two cards.  One sentimental and one funny.  The funny one had a picture of a dog flying through the air and the inside said something like, “Party like the gate was left open.”  I thought it was funny.

    I also brought cake pops to the celebration…so really I’m not sure why I needed to get presents at all. 😉

    Happy Birthday Mama Sue!

    The cake pops were a hit for sure!

    So much love…or forced hugging?

     

    Good weekend all around and I still had leftover cakepops and cake balls to bring to work Monday…which got devoured in about 5 seconds.  And even a few sitting in my freezer that we didn’t get a chance to decorate.  A few less treats to make for Christmas!!  (P.S.  Did you check out my tree?)

    Have a lovely Tuesday everyone!

    *~Amanda aka Semi-Health Nut~*



    Have you ever made cake pops?  How was your experience?

    What does your family do to celebrate birthdays?  We go to the same pizza place everytime and I make some sort of dessert. 🙂

    Check out my holiday link-up!!  Link your fav recipes/decor ideas and find others to try yourself!  🙂 http://semihealthyblog.com/2011/12/sweet-cinnamon-biscuits-recipe-round-up/  (closes Dec 27th)

    Linked to:
    Tempt my Tummy Tuesdays

    Related

    Filed Under: birthday, dessert, family Tagged With: birthday, dessert, family

    About Amanda R DeWitt

    I’m a writer, chocolate chip cookie baker, blog designer, power walker, Instagram fiend, peanut butter toast lover and copious coffee drinker living in Nebraska with my husband and three cats. (also a fan of a good run-on sentence)

    Previous Post: « Salted Candy Bar Cookies
    Next Post: {WIAW #9} Weekend Eats »

    Primary Sidebar

    Dig into the Archives

    Browse the Categories

    Dessert is the Best

    S’mores Cookie Dough Pie in a Skillet

    S'mores cookie dough pie in skillet

    Grilled S’mores Banana Boats

    grilled s'mores banana boats before and after

    Banana Funfetti protein Cookies

    banana funfetti protein cookies via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

    {WIAW #42} Mexican Tacos and Dessert Fail

    Chewy Almond Funfetti Cookies + 7 Happy Things

    chewy almond funfetti cookies via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com perfect for customizing for any holiday including the 4th of july! #yum #recipe #cookies #dessert

    {WIAW #66} Moving Day + Archive Eats

    [IMM Link-Up #9] Chocolate Covered Strawberries

    chocolate covered strawberries with sprinkles with sprinkles

    GF Pumpkin Spice Browned Butter Protein Bites

    gf pumpkin spice browned butter protein bites via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

    Raspberry Homemade Fruit Roll Ups with Frozen Fruit

    easy DIY homemade fruit roll ups. great as a snack, a semi-healthy treat, or for fueling for a run. via @semihealthnut at semihealthyblog.com

    Frozen Banana Pops Covered in Chocolate Taste Like Dilly Bars

    See More >>

    Popular Today

    Whole Wheat Lemon Snickerdoodle Cookie
    {Fitness Friday #2} 18 Week Half-Marathon Training + Cold Weather Running
    A Marvelous Christmas 2013
    Friday Five: New Lake + Other Randoms
    Merry Christmas + Happy Holidays
    All Studied Up and Smart and All
    {Review} Luna Bar: Nutz Over Chocolate
    Thanksgiving 2011 Baking and Family Time
    "Weighty Woes" Part 1: Ups and downs of Weight by my dear Mama Sue (On a journey to lose 50 pounds the healthy way!)
    New Blog Design 2014

    Tags

    banana (16) birthday (15) blogging + writing (56) Blogging 101 (17) chicken (15) chocolate (19) Christmas (18) coffee (12) confessions (13) cookies (48) dessert (32) Did You Know (22) family (42) fitness (82) food (47) Friday Finds (36) giveaway (16) guest post (47) holiday (14) life (17) link-love (14) link-up (31) MIMM (38) Monday Moves (14) nutrition (21) peanutbutter (22) positivity (15) pumpkin (21) ramble (16) recipe (63) restaurant (22) review (21) running (24) salad (13) school (32) semi-healthy (16) smoothie (16) thankful (23) Thursday Thoughts (17) tips (15) twin cities (27) Uncategorized (17) vegetarian (14) weekend (20) zoeyfluffybutt (14)

    Random Random Posts..Good Luck!

    Double Chocolate Whole Wheat Cookie Goodness

    Being Thankful…Even in Tough Situations

    Justin’s Nut Butter Raffle + Half Marathon Training Update

    {Friday Five Foodie Finds # 16} Here’s to Feeling Better!

    {Thursday Thoughts} Your Problems, My Problems

    Happy Birthday Sister + Granola Teaser

    Nutty Coconut Cupcakes [ Gluten Free + Higher Protein ]

    Semi-Healthy Partying

    {MIMM #21} Adventures in Moving

    Happy Things #5: Good News

    Footer

    Random Recipe Machine…Refresh for More!

    {Vegetarian Curious #1} Katie’s Story

    gluten free and vegan nutty power bites via @semihealthnut recipe at semihealthyblog.com

    Nutty M+M Power Bites Recipe

    Friday Five Foodie Finds #14

    {Friday Five Foodie Finds #22} Housekeeping

    {WIAW #26} Almost Better

    The *Art* of the Hodge-Podge Cookie… (which for today is: Butterscotch, Oatmeal, Almond, Protein Powder Cookie)

    Easy Breakfast + DIY Running Headband

    *Coffee Love* + Nutritional Info (Also R.I.P. Mr. Coffee)

    Copyright © 2026 Diary of a Semi-Health Nut · By Amanda R. DeWitt